Write an adjudicatory essay concerning the dispute between Kane and Pereboom on the question of whether we have free will. Your task involves both explication and evaluation, though in this case there are two positions to explicate and to evaluate, Kane’s and Pereboom’s. You should begin your essay with a clear formulation of the problem that Kane and Pereboom are discussing, and an account of why it is a problem. You should go on to explicate and evaluate both Kane’s and Pereboom’s positions on this problem. You may organize this part of your paper in whatever way seems best: you may do the explications first and then follow with criticism, or you may combine them as you go along. Finally, you should conclude the essay by trying to provide an assessment of the relative strengths and weaknesses of these two positions on the problem under discussion.